Due to the Horrific Types of Crimes
being perpetrated in Today’s Society Should Scientists Continue Looking for Biological
Causes of Crime?
By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
When addressing this specific question the first issue that would come to the
mind of any student who has been involved in any form of academia would be the
immediate questioning of the individual who could possibly come up with a
question where they are asking if scientists should continue looking for
biological causes of criminality. This would basically be asking should
scientists be scientists and do research regarding a question that has had several
disciplines searching for an answer to this issue for thousands of years.
However, in all fairness to the question, and the individual asking this
particular question, I feel we must explore, discuss, and present some of the
history behind the actual earlier research which was conducted by scientists,
researchers, and scholars and what they proffered and what actions they advised
should be taken based upon their research, hypotheses, and theories pertaining
to the causation of crime.
The most logical place to begin is with stating that the earlier biological
theories focused on anatomical, physiological, and genetic abnormalities
possessed by the individual which they believed actually served to separate
those who violated the law and those to obeyed the law. In addition to this
narrow minded view they also came to the conclusion that there was a relatively
miniscule amount of affect on the individuals by the social environment they
were living and functioning within, thus basically advising Sociologists that
their work and their theories were really irrelevant to the causation of
criminal behavior.
Biological Positivism is what the earlier school of thought pertaining to
biological factors causing criminal behavior was called and this theoretical approach
replaced the previously popular classical school of criminology. Classical
criminology basically held that people were rational and that they calculated
pain and pleasure and exercised free will to commit or not to commit a criminal
act., therefore they had a choice in what they did and did it voluntarily and
were responsible for their actions (Barkan, 2008).
However, Biological Positivism did not share the same thought process as
Classical Criminology since they believed that crime was not really a
rationally reasoned behavior using assessments, making choices and using free
will to commit criminal acts. The Biological Positivists believed that criminal
activities are a direct result of inborn abnormalities of which there were no
assessments, choice or free will used to decide to, or not to, commit a crime.
They also believed that situations in life and environment could restrain or
provoke criminal behavior, however these do no cause criminal behavior. They
espoused that the real criminal was actually born a criminal and born with
criminal traits which would cause the person to be at odds with civilized
society and that is what caused him to commit crimes. The Biological Positivist
believed that criminals were inherently defective and biological inferior to
law abiding individuals (Lombroso, as cited in Herman, 1997).
In 1876 Cesar Lombroso wrote the Criminal Man and he actually transformed the
study of criminals from metaphysicians, penologists, and moralists to a
biological science. Lombroso’s focus was mainly on the physical characteristics
of the individual and from his comparisons of prisoners against Italian
soldiers and from this comparisons he concluded criminals were physically
different from law abiding citizens, Lombroso did not take into consideration
any of the physical training and nutrition received by the soldiers and the
lack of nutrition and lack of physical exercise of the prisoners, or any other
valid variables which could have had an influence on the correlation and should
have been controlled for in the study. He decided that criminals were born this
way and had the physical make-up, mental characteristics, instincts, and mental
capabilities of a primitive man (Herman, 1997). Lombroso set up a list of
certain physical characteristics which he stated were inherent in these born
criminals and if a man was identified as possessing five of these
characteristics then he was labeled and marked as a born criminal. In addition
to the born criminal Lombroso recognized two other types which he labeled
criminaloid, which he advised were motivated by passion or have an emotional
makeup which compels the person to comit crime under the correct circumstances.
The other category of insane criminals which were included by Lombroso included
epileptic, imbecile, idiot, and the psychotic. Lombroso first believed the
great majority of criminals as born criminal and later he revised his thought
to 35% and added more economic, social and political conditions as causation
and factors in crime. One of the major problems with this though process was
that the theory brought into its reach certain races and categories of people
as being inferior and as being born criminals which is seen as discriminatory
(Lombroso as cited in Herman, 1997).
The following individuals also conducted research and proffered theories
pertaining to Biological Positivism and once we discuss them we will have a
better understanding as to the original question posed to us in this
assignment. Charles Goring was a medical officer who wrote the English Convict
in 1913 which were the findings of a long study he conducted involving
convicts, soldiers, hospital patients, professors, university undergraduates
and his studied proved that Lombroso was wrong. Goring accepted Lombroso’s
theory that criminals are born but rejected his theory criminals as an
evolutionary atavism. Goring dismissed any effects of social factors on
individuals committing criminal acts and proposed criminals are inherently
different to people who obeyed the law. He found significant statistical
differences between civilians and criminals in the areas of weight and body
stature, and to have lower IQ’s which resulted in his proffering criminals
suffered from defective intelligence and from defective physique and later included
moral defectiveness to include recidivists (Goring, 1913).
An Anthropologist E.A. Hooton wrote Crime and man in 1939 and attacked Goring
in both his methodology and his conclusions regarding criminals via his 17,000
subject study and the typology of the prisoners and the civilians was
accomplished within an elaborate typology of nationality and racial groups and
another typology of criminal offenses. Hooton, and his associates, concluded
that sociological factors were not important due to the fact that criminals are
basically inherently inferior to non-criminals in their makeup. He believed the
primary cause of criminal actions originates from biological inferiority.
Hooton found Goring’s techniques deficient and Hooton’s work was also found to
be criticized on several grounds. His population had police and fireman who
were selected for their professions due to their physical stature to name one
critical flaw. His reasoning was a case for circular reasoning and there was no
way to falsify his theory and the theory was said to be true because it was
true (Hunt, 1991). In the findings of Lombroso, Goring, and Hooton social and
environmental factors were seen as incidental when they were compared to the
certain destiny of the born physical criminals, because these individuals were
born with a criminal nature because they had a defective and inferior biology
which had determined them to be criminals and exhibit criminal behavior (Alers,
& Sellers, 2009).
There was a major criticism of Biological Determinism by the sociologist for
their ignoring or providing insufficient attention to social and economic
issues, methodological flaws, lack of evidence to support their theories, and
regard their theories as unfounded and inconsequential. In the recent decades
it appears that publications on Biological Theories seem to be flourishing and
they are in prominent journals. One of the most important things to remember
regarding the earlier Biological Positivism Theories is as Akers and Sellers
(2009) advise that “Much of the objection to biological theory is based on its
controversial implications for policy. But the major reason for the rejection
of the earlier biological theories has in reality very little to do with
disciplinary or policy issues. It is simply because the theories were found to
be un-testable, illogical, or wrong. They seldom withstood empirical tests and
often espoused simplistic racist and sexist notions that easily crumbled under
closer scrutiny. Even the strongest supporters of modern biological theories of
crime and delinquency recognize that the discrediting of Lombrosian positivism
was due to the serious methodological flows of these early studies and the
weakness of their efforts to integrate their findings with sociological theory
and data.” (Mednick, 1987 as cited in Aker and Seller, 2009). Biological
criminology was seen as being simplistic and also unscientific Fishbein, 1990,
as cited in Akers and Sellers, 2009), and often based on ideologically based
studies, including some from Nazi Germany (Mednick, 1987).
At this point the issue “Should scientists continue looking for biological
causes of criminality?” will be addressed in that current biological theorists
reject the kind of simplistic biological determinism used by Biological Positivism.
The newer biological research is founded on newer discoveries and also on new
technical advances in the area of genetics, neurology, brain functioning, and
biochemistry. The focus of today’s biological research is in the areas of
biochemistry, heritability, hormonal imbalances, metabolism, IQ, genetics,
neurophysiology, central, autonomic nervous system, and neurotransmitters. The
new course the biological researchers have taken advise that behavior results
from the interaction of the biological makeup of the human organism with the
physical and social environment, which is something completely opposite from
what the original Biological Positivism espoused specifically against the field
of sociology. Behavioral potentials and susceptibilities they propose, can be
triggered by biological factors, these factors interact with and also can be
affected by the physical and social environment in which the person is exposed
to. Basically we see that criminal behavior results from the interaction of
biology, behavior, and the environment. Many of the new researchers are calling
their endeavors biosocial rather than biological because of the acknowledgement
of the social aspects of this activity. Ellis and Walsh, (1997 p. 259) pretty
much sum it up by stating “the explanation of criminal behavior are likely to
involve complex interplays among learning and genetic, hormonal, and
neurochemical factors all operating within a complex evolved social system. We
also see that genes make people different and they also make people sensitive
to environmental cues and modulate a person’s responses to these particular
cues or environmental situations. There genes which of course actually lead to
the development of different traits and characteristics which may increase the
probability of criminal behavior when a person is in certain environments and
in some situations which are encountered in life (Sapolsky, 2004).
Today we see that the modern biological research and theories rely on greater
theoretical sophistication which has always been identified as lacking the
original theories, and there is less reliance on immutable biological destiny
or defects with a more heightened focus on the interaction of the individual
with psychological and social variables. In addition there is a more advanced
understanding and knowledge of bodily systems, neurological, hormonal
activities, genetics, and a more sophisticated theoretical methodology. The
focus now for biological researches is that there is little proof to disagree
with that assertion that biology interacts with the environment (Sapolsky,
2004).
The real question involves the nature of that interaction and the extent to
which crime is influenced by biology or environment. The biological aspects
must include association and interaction with the social or
social-psychological factors. With the disengagement from the theories of
Lombroso, Goring, and Hooton and the new positive view towards the interaction
of biological, psychological and sociological aspects being a combined cause for
criminal behavior there continues to be a definite need for scientists to
continue looking for biological causes of criminality, be there proof or
disproof of the theories they propose. The identification of the lack of and
numerous methodological deficiencies including proper sample size, bias, lack
of good statistical procedures, a good amount of generalizability, and are
exceedingly inadequate in addressing relevant issues being addressed and
examined and ambiguously reporting of results. All of these issues and
criticisms were known by the current biological researchers and were used to
guide their paths in current biological research which is benefit to all.
Because of these deficiencies in past research the newer researchers have
forged a path espousing the greater extent to which a biological theory
proposes to relate normal physiological and sensory processes to social and
environmental variables in explaining criminal behavior and this is a positive
direction and one which will be empirically supported and accepted in the
criminological field of research and study. The true and accurate question
which must be continually examined, explored and researched by biologist,
psychologist, psychiatrists, sociologists, and criminologists involves the fact
that “There is little to disagree with in the assertion that biology interacts
with the environment. The real question involves the nature of that interaction
and the extent to which crime is influenced by biology or environment.” (Akers
& Seller, 2009, p. 66).
When we look at the endeavors of the past Biological Positivist we see their
skewed views, ideas and inaccurate perception of which people are criminals.
Even though their theories were incorrect and not accepted, the various
disciplines learned from the work they did and also came to better understand
what was and was not a viable reasoning for causation of criminal behaviors.
Even from the negative we learn and know what to do in future research in these
critical areas of research. Any ethical research is a positive and can assist
in the understanding of human beings and their actions. The manner in which the
previous biological researchers performed lead the modern biological
researchers in a better and more acceptable paths for critical research in the
area of biological and genetic issues which when combined with psychological
and sociological aspects are critical to the true understanding of human
behavior and the causation of criminal behavior.
New Biological Research
Biological theories received praise hundreds of years ago with such beliefs as
phrenology, which is the study of the skull and its shape and form which was
performed by but over time dissipated in plausibility and popularity. It should
be noted the first philosopher to locate mental facilities in the head was
Aristotle; however Franz Joseph Gall was the founder of Phrenology and was a
physiologist and an anatomist. He began his study of medicine at Strassburg and
then began his practice as a physician. However, his energies were mainly
devoted to the scientific investigation of problems which actually occupied his
attention from boyhood. Gall generalized humans as having a powerful memory
which is invariably associated with prominent eyes and through observation he
could discern special talents for painting, music, and other arts. He believed
talents and dispositions of men are dependent upon the functions of the brain,
and they may be inferred with perfect exactitude and precision from the
external appearances of the skull (Simpson, 2005).
The story of Phrenology actually runs from rags to riches in that it went from
it peaking in popularity to the actual depths of ignominious obscurity. Today
with the advent of medical scanning technology. Phrenology is enjoying a
renewed public interest. Due to the use of CT scans and MRI’s it has become
clear mental functions occur in specific areas of the brain. These tests have
now provided the confirmation of the first tenant of Phrenology. However, it is
not yet known if this vindicates the ideas of Dr. Gall, Dr. Spurzheim, and Mr.
Combe (VanWyhe, 2004). Advents in modern science and medicine has led to the
reinvention of biological theories are researchers examine genetics, hormones,
neurotransmitters, diet, and allergies as etiologies of criminal behavior
(Barkan, 2008).
According to these theories crime arises from biological differences within
individuals which have the effect of making them more prone or susceptible to
committing deviant acts or crimes than other individuals without this biological
aspect in their physiology.
There is a large amount of studies which have provided the proof regarding the
differences between the brain composition of violent individuals and those of
the non violent individuals. Future research will be required in this area
which should continue to produce reliable, replicable evidence demonstrating
the nexus between various biological aspects of human physiology and the
differences between criminals and non criminals (Sapolsky, 2004). It appears
that biological theories will only gain credibility in upcoming years when more
tangible evidence surfaces over time. In recent years the biological aspects of
antisocial personality, crime, and violent behavior has been increasingly
recognized. Several authors have stressed an association between impulsive
violence and cerebral lesions (Elliott, 1992).
Pillman, Rohde, Ulrich, Draba, Sannemuller, & Marneros, (1999) studied the
relationship of EEG abnormalities and violent criminal behavior in 222
defendants referred for psychiatric evaluation. There was no connection between
the number of violent offenses and EEG abnormalities in general. The authors
observed focal abnormalities of the left hemisphere which were related to a
significantly higher number of violent offenses. The findings suggest that
impairment of the left hemisphere functions may enhance the propensity for
violent behavior in a subgroup of offenders.
In recent years the biological aspects of deviant behavior, antisocial
personality, crime, and violent behavior have been increasingly recognized.
There has been a demonstrated association between impulsive behavior, impulsive
violence, and cerebral lesions. In 129 violent offenders, s strong correlation
was found between neurological soft signs and the number of former convictions
and early recidivism (Convit, Czobor, & Volavka, 1987). Wong, Lumsden,
& Fenton, 1994) investigated inmates of a high security special hospital
and specifically focused on a sub-group with the highest degree of violence was
found an increased number of focal abnormalities In this group the focal
abnormalities appeared to be in the temporal region. This same study
demonstrated an association of violence and temporally located morphological
lesions on cerebral computed tomography.
These findings were supported by a study which found left temporal focal
activity in three of four subjects with repetitive impulsive violence. The
electrophysiological data are supported by computed tomographic and PET
findings (Volkow & Tancredi, 1987).
Miller, (1988) hypothesized in some criminals a neurodevelopmental maturation
deficit affecting the dominant hemisphere of the brain may be the cause of a
relative inability to use inner speech to modulate perception, thought, and
then behavior. When there individuals are placed under stressful condition of
social stress they regress back to using developmentally immature responses to
the situations presented to them.
There is some evidence that neurodevelopmental insults can affect adult
personality. Neugebauer, Hoek, & Susser (1999) reported that makes who had
been exposed in utero to the Dutch famine of 1944-1945 had an increased
likelihood of acquiring a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder in
adulthood.
Sapolsky (2004) advised that the first study by Raine in 1994 demonstrated that
aggressive behavior has been thought to come from the operation of a part of
the brain called the limbic system under certain circumstances. The amygdla is
the structure in the brain most often implicated in this behavior. Refrontal
functions may provide an individual with the capacity to exercise judgment in
the setting of complex social situations in which the actions which are taken
can high significant consequences. Depending on the situation this capacity for
judgment may serve the function of inhibiting limbic impulses, which could be
socially inappropriate. There is a balance between the potential for impulsive
aggression mediated by temporolimbic structures and the control of this drive
by the influence of the oribitofrontal regions. This theory of violence has
been reinforced via neuroimaging studies.
Some areas of the brain are very specifically associated with certain
behaviors. The hypothalamus is a small structure on the basil surface of the
brain which controls drive states such as hunger, thirst and sexual behavior.
If there is damage sustained to this area, and depending on the specific area
which is lesioned, the result can be compulsive eating to the point of obesity,
or in severe changes of sexual drive. There are several brain structures and
groups of structures when if damaged can generate behaviors which may be
associated with deviant or criminal behavior. The temporal lobe is a major
division of the brain’s lower lateral surface or cortex, in both the left and
right hemispheres. Both memory and learning are among the cognitive function
this region controls. It is also part of a larger system of the brain called
the limbic system which regulates emotional behavior. If there is damage to the
temporal lobe then this can be associated with a distinct loss of a person’s
memory for events, impaired comprehension of language, and with aggressiveness
and deviant and violent behavior Devinsky & Bear, 1984).
A further examination of this area shows that in addition to the temporal lobe
the limbic system consists of brain structures which are located below the
surface of the brain. These subcortical structures are involved in the
primitive aspects of emotional behavior and damage to any part of a variety of
limbic system structures could result in aggression or violence,
hypersexuality, or even rage. In addition, a person could also experience loss
of control over their aggression, and experience explosive episodes needing
only the minimal of stimuli as provocation, all of this can come out of an
individual having limbic system lesions (Devinsly & Bear, 1984).
The frontal lobe is large and it is the most anterior area of each hemisphere’s
surface which lies behind the frontal bone in the skull. The frontal lobe is
considered to be the most complex structure in the human brain. The frontal
lobe is not considered fully developed until adolescences and it is what is
intricately involved in a person’s self-regulation regarding a person’s
behavior, judgment, planning, organizing and a person’s personality. Damage to
this area is associated with gross disturbances in all of the aforementioned
items it controls and regulates. Damage to this specific area of the brain is
specifically relevant to criminal situations because it impairs those cognitive
functions associated with an individual’s self-regulating behavior. If this
mechanism is not functioning properly a person could make irrational decisions
or be unable to control behavioral impulses, or accurately evaluate
consequences of their actions resulting in deviant and or criminal behavior
being manifested (Winslade, 2002).
Research between hormones and antisocial, aggressive behavior illustrates the
complexities of biology, behavior relations, and it is clearly demonstrated
that the influence of the social context on biological functioning (Dabbs,
1992), (Susman, 1993). There is convincing evidence from a wide number of
behavioral studies form a link between high testosterone and increased
aggressive and violent behavior in adults.
High testosterone I associated with both high dominance and high socioeconomic
status, and while experience of success increases testosterone, failure reduces
it (Dabbs, 1992), (Archer, 1991). Neurotramsmitter and toxin research is also
beginning to provide evidence of interactions with social and environmental
processes. Moffitt, Caspi, Fawcett, Brammer, Raleigh, Yuwiler, A, & Silva,
(1997) found that violent offenders had higher blood serotonin levels than
controls, those with both high blood serotonin and a conflicted family
background were over three times more likely to become violent by age 21
compared to men with on high serotonin or with on conflicted family
backgrounds. Masters, Hone, and Doshi (1998) examined 1,242 counties within the
United States and found a three-way interaction between environmental lead or
manganese exposure, high population density, and alcoholism rates, with highest
rates of violence in counties with high densities, exposure to toxins, and
alcoholism.
Neurotransmitters are chemical substances found in the brain which assist
neurons transmit impulses. Researchers have discovered linked such as the
aforementioned, levels of certain neurotransmitters with high levels of violent
and aggressive behavior, thus resulting in a nexus between biology and criminal
behavior. We see that the advances in modern biological researcher has created
a better and more acceptable path for critical research in the area of
biological and genetic issues which when combined with psychological and
sociological aspects are critical to the true understanding of human behavior
and the causation of criminal behavior.
Biological Research and its Racist, Sexist, and Class-based Stereo-types
Could such research be attacked on grounds that it promotes racist, sexist, or
class-based stereo-types is another question and this an issue which is a valid
question in that strictly biological theories can lead to statements and mind
sets which could be construed to promote certain types of negative behavior .
These theories and the theorists could interpret the best manner in which to
deal with criminal behaviors in ways that could be seen as prejudice against
certain genders, certain cultural groups, certain races, which could result in
proposing seriously negative actions against individuals who are identified as
being part of certain groups.
Lombroso suggested and assumed that whites were actually superior to non-whites
and this was by heredity. Lombroso also assumed and suggested that Africans
were the first human beings that evolved upwards and positively to yellow and
then up to whites. Lombroso also advised that racial development was truly
signified by social progress from primitive to modern. Lombroso advised he
believed that on we white people have actually reached the ultimate symmetry
and of properly and acceptable form, which was basically advising white’s were
superior to Africans, which in turn created a racist view of on race over
another (Lombroso, as cited in Herman, 1997).
Goring suggested that the people who were identified as being born with
criminal traits are inherently inferior to law-abiding individuals. Goring
believed this individuals to have lower intelligence levels and they were
defective in the areas of physical, intelligence, and morally (Goring, 1913).
Hooton stated that “we had not realized how many of these New Americans were
going to wave automatics instead of American flags, and hold up the corner
grocery store rather than uphold the Constitution.” (Hooton, 1939a p. 131).
Hooton defined Negro criminals as “The most underprivileged human group in this
country ”(Hooton, 1939a p 290) and who were of African-American decent, while
Negroids were simply members of the Negro race into which the incessant seepage
of White and Indian blood and have brought about a multiplication of physical
types (Hooton, 1939a p.291). In addition Hooton had a very strong tie to
eugenics which is the science of improving a species via controlled breading
and reproduction. He also felt that paroled offenders could be allowed to
inhabit a certain segregated areas which should be provided for them by either
the state of federal government. However, he favored permanent incarceration of
individuals who were so genetically inferior they should not be allowed to
procreate (Jones, 1986). Hooton’s work was also criticized for its racist
overtones and for his blatant disregard for of characteristics which could have
been considered to be important and which seemed to be of benefit to his
results, in addition to the fact that he never actually presented any real
tangible evidence that criminal deviance was actually in fact biologically
inherited (Shafer, 1969).
Taylor suggested an intrusion into the lives of anyone who was diagnosed with
any type of a genetically predisposed to the commission of crimes, and this
included people diagnosed whether or not they had actually committed a criminal
act or not. He advocated isolation, lobotomies, ingestion of chemicals, and
also gene splicing to deal with this problem ( Taylor , 1984). Rowe (2002)
suggested and supported a form of voluntary eugenics as a possibility for
future behavioral genetics to control criminal behavior. Akers & Sellers,
(2009) advises that certain medical procedures such as brain surgery,
electrodes, and chemical castration were all used on individuals in the attempt
to control and stop criminal behavior due to the belief that there needed to be
an alteration of the individuals physiology.
If individuals from one particular race, gender, nationality, or culture falls
into the category of possessing traits described by the various physiological
or biological attributes that race, gender, nationality, or culture will be
unjustly discriminated against if the Biological Positivism was supported.
Could such research be attacked on grounds that it promotes racist, sexist, or
class-based stereo-types is another question and this an issue which is a valid
question in that strictly biological theories can lead to statements and mind
sets which could be construed to promote certain types of negative behavior.
The answer to this question appears to be a yes just based upon the limited
amount of information provided in the aforementioned paragraphs from the
existing research in this area.
References
Archer, J. (1991).
The influence of testosterone on human aggression. British Journal of Clinical
Psychology, 82, 1-28.
Barkan, S. E. (2008).
Criminology: A sociological understanding (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River , NJ :
Prentice Hall.
Bartol, C.R. (1995).
Criminal Behavior: A Psychological Approach (4th ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
Cohen, L. &
Swift, S. (1993). A public health approach to the violence epidemic in the
United States . Environmental and Urbanization Vol. 5, No 2, October pp. 50-66.
Crutchfield, R.D.,
Bridges, G.S., Weis, J.G. (1996). Crime, Pine Forge Press.
Cooney, M. (2006).
The criminological potential of pure sociology. Crime, law and social change,
46 (1), 51-64.
Dabbs, J. M. (1992).
Testosterone measurements in social and clinical psychology. Journal of Social
and Clinical Psychology, 11, 302-321.
Devinsky, O. &
Bear, D. (1984). Varieties of aggressive behavior in temporal lobe epilepsy.
American Journal of Psychiatry 141: pp.651-656.
Dolan, M., &
Doyle, M. (2000). Violence Risk Prediction: clinical and actuarial measures and
the role of the psychopathy check list. British Journal of Psychiatry, 177
pp.303-311.
Elliot, F.A. (1992).
Violence the neurological contributions: an overview Arch Neurol 1992;
49:595-602.
Friedel, R.O. (2004).
Dopamine dysfunction in borderline personality disorder: a hypothesis.
Neuropsychopharmacology, 29 (6), 1029-1045.
Gibson, J. J. (1996).
The senses considered as perceptual systems. Boston .
Goring, C.B. (1913).
The English Convict: A Statistical Study London: H.M.S.O., reprint, Montclair ,
New Jersey : Patterson Smith, 1972.
Hayward , v., Astley,
O.R., Cruz-Hernandez, M., Grant, D., Robles-De-La-Torre, G. (2004). Haptic
interfaces and devices, Sensor Review 24(1).
Herman, A. (1997).
"The Idea of Decline in Western History". pp. 110–113.
Burke, R.(2001) An
Introduction to Criminological Theory. Willam Publishing, Devon
Hunt, E.E. (1991).
The old and the new physical anthropology in the careers of E.A. Hooton and
W.M. Krogman. American journal of human biology, 3,(6), 563-569.
Jones, D.A. (1986).
History of criminology: A philosophical perspective. New York : Greenwood
Press.
Lombroso, as cited in
Herman, A. (1997). “The Idea of Decline in Western History”. P. 116.
Masters, R. D., Hone, B., & Doshi, A. (1998). Environmental pollution,
neurotoxicity, and criminal violence. In J. Rose (Ed.), Environmental
toxicology: Current developments (pp. 13-48). New York : Gordon and Breach.
McIlwaine, C. &
Moser, C. (2001). Violence and social capital in urban poor communities:
perspectives from Colombia and Guatemala . Journal of International Development
Vol. 13, No 7, pp.965-984.
Miller, L. (1988).
Neuropsychological perspectives on delinquency. Behavioral Science Law 6: pp.409-428.
Moffitt, T. E.,
Caspi, A., Fawcett, P., Brammer, G. L., Raleigh , M., Yuwiler, A,, & Silva,
P. (1997). Whole blood serotonin and family background relate to male violence.
In A. Raine, P. A. Brennan, D. P. Farrington, & S. A. Mednick (Eds.), Biosocial
bases of violence (pp. 231-249). New York : Plenum.
Pillmann, F, Rohde,
A., Ulrich, S., Draba, S., Sannemuller, & Marneros, A. (1999). Violence,
criminal behavior, and the eeg: significance of left hemispheric focal
abnormalities. Journal of Neuropsyhiatry Clinical Neuro Science 11:4 Fall.
Rowe , D.C. (2002).
Biology and Crime. Los Angeles : Roxbury.
Sapolsky, R. M.
(2004). The frontal cortex and the criminal justice system, philosophical
transactions of the royal society. Biological Sciences 359, no. 1451 pp.1787
-1796.
Simpson, D. (2005).
Phrenologyand the neurosciences: contributions of F.J. Gall and J.G.
Spurzheim ANZ Journal
of Surgery. Oxford . Vol.75.6; pp. 475.
Susman, E. J. (1993).
Psychological, contextual, and psychobiological interactions: A developmental
perspective on conduct disorder. Development and Psychopathology, 5, 181-189.
Shafer, S. (1969).
Theories in criminology: Past and present philosophies of the crime problem.
New York : Random House.
Taylor, L. (1984).
Born to Crime: The Genetic Causes of Criminal Behavior. Westport CT : Greenwood
.
Van Wyhe, J. (2004).
Phrenology and the origins of Victorian scientific naturalism, Ashgate
Publishing Company pp. 27.
Volkow, N.D, &
Tancredi, L. (1987). Neural substrates of violent behavior: trait and state.
Journal of Psyhiatry 151: pp.668-673.
Winslade, W.J.
(2002). Traumatic brain injury and legal responsibility. In Marcus S.J. (ed.).
Neuroethics: Mapping the Field Conference Proceedings May 13-14, 2002, San
Francisco , California . Dana Press: New York , 2002:pp.74-82.