Sunday, January 17, 2016

Sutherland’s Differential Association Theory and how it relates to Criminal Behavior

Sutherland’s Differential Association Theory and how it relates to Criminal Behavior

BY: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

Criminal behavior is learnable and learned in interaction along with other deviant individuals. Through association people learn techniques of certain crimes, motives, and rationale for committing criminal acts. Here ones can see the critical aspect of Differential Association Theory which are the frequency and duration of the associations. This particular theory explains why an individual migrates towards deviant behavior. His theory is very useful when used to explain peer influences among deviant offenders, and when attempting to explain the how of becoming a criminal. In this theory Sutherland attributes the cause of crime to the social context of individuals. The principle of Differential Association asserts a person becomes delinquent due to an excess of definitions favorable to violation of law over definitions unfavorable to law. This theory explains why individuals migrate towards criminal behavior (Sutherland, 1974).

Sutherland’s theory has nine postulates. Criminal behavior is learned, and it is learned in interaction and association with other persons in a process of communication. The principal part of learning criminal behavior occurs within intimate personal groups. This learning involves various techniques of committing the crime, which at times are simple and at other times complex. This learning also involves specific directions, rationalizations, attitudes, and drives. The learning of specific direction of motives and drives is learned from definitions from the legal codes as being either unfavorable or favorable based upon the categorization by society via the legislators. When a person is exposed to a large amount or excess of definitions favorable to violation of the law over definitions against the violation of law they will become delinquent or commit deviant acts. This is an important concept because when people become criminals they become criminals because they do so due to their contacts with criminal patterns and also because of the isolation from the anti-criminal patterns, and the exposure to neutral associations really have either little or no effect on criminal behavior (Moon, Hwang, & McCluskey, 2011; Sutherland, 1974).

When examining Differential Association there are four issues which have a definite bearing on its taking effect on a person or a child, they are intensity, frequency, priority, and duration. Priority is important through selective intensity and influences. There is also the aspect of the prestige of the actual source of the criminal pattern being learned from, and the emotional reactions related to this particular association. A common aspect of this theory is that the process of learning anything is by association involves all of the normal mechanisms involved in any other learning. Both criminal and non-criminal behavior are both explained by general needs and values, both do what they do to obtain money, one is done with the mechanisms which are within the law and the other does them outside of the law (Moon, Hwang, & McCluskey, 2011; Sutherland, 1974).

It appears that deviance occurs when people define a certain human situation as an appropriate occasion for violating social norms or the criminal laws. The definitions of the situations are acquired through an individual’s history of past experience and particularly in terms of past associations with others (Pfohl, 1994). When Sutherland presented his theory he did not mean mere association with criminals would lead to criminal behavior. However, Sutherland viewed crime and criminal behavior as a consequence of conflicting to values. What Sutherland meant was an excess of criminal definitions will be more susceptible to new criminal definitions, and when this occurs the individuals will be less receptive to anti-criminal definitions.

When further examining Sutherland's theory of differential association it becomes   evident that it can be categorized as a learning theory. The basic premise of this theory is that criminal behavior is acquired through the learning process, just as is lawful behavior. The theory demonstrates that the socialization process is essentially the same, regardless of whether the messages being transmitted are conventional or deviant. It is through the interaction with others that people learn attitudes which are both favorable and unfavorable as relates to the violation of laws. Sutherland claims that a person turns to criminal behavior when there is an excess of attitudes and values favoring law violation as opposed to adherence to the law (Sutherland, 1974).  The activities which comprise the basic tenets of theory are directly applicable to the learning of bullying and violent behavior by children in a school environment.

In theory, and as a learning theory, differential association is one of the most logical explanations of criminal behavior. When using differential association to explain criminal behavior the researcher must look at criminal behavior after it has taken place with the goal of reconstructing the reality of the criminal's world prior to and at the time the actions were committed (Lilly, Cullen & Ball, 1995). The actions demonstrated by children in school are directly in line with Sutherland’s belief that criminal behavior develops from associating with those individuals who commit crimes or in this case bullying, and that commission of crimes was more likely to result from learned behaviors which have been positively reinforced. Motivations and technical knowledge, according to Sutherland (1974), were likely to be learned from those who commit crimes.

The principle of differential association asserts that a person becomes delinquent because they are constantly exposed to a excess of meanings favorable to violation(s) of law over definitions unfavorable to the violation(s) of law. In other words, criminal behavior emerges when a person is exposed to more social messages from those around them favoring conduct that is anti-social rather than pro-social (Sutherland, 1974). According to Tittle (1986, p. 429), "despite some important anomalies, our findings support the major theme of Sutherland's thinking. Association with criminal definitely does seem to be a generator of crime, and it appears to exercise its influence indirectly through its effects on a learned symbolic construct-motivation to engage in criminal behavior."

The learning process posited in differential association involves the same mechanisms whether a person is learning criminal behavior or learning conformity to social norms and laws. The data collected from both law enforcement agencies demonstrate that the majority of the home-invasion robberies were committed by more than two perpetrators. These groups can provide the social messages from those around them favoring conduct that is anti-social rather than pro-social as discussed by Sutherland (1974) in his explanation of the foundational tenet in Differential Association.

Perpetrators of school violence knowingly and voluntarily commit these actions and there exists a very good possibility that they are aware that these are considered to be very serious offenses with very serious consequences attached to them if they are caught, prosecuted and convicted. However, the value they place on committing these acts with their peers, and with the positive reinforcement from their peers, appears to outweigh the rational thought process or decision making process that someone about to engage in any activity, who assesses the gain and loss ratio, would see as being very high on the cost and low on the return scale, and reconsider engaging in once the situation was rationally evaluated. The more often these activities are performed and the more times a benefit is gained in the form of participant peer reinforcement is accomplished, along with acceptance by the other peers and the group, the more reinforced the learned behavior is solidified as being acceptable notwithstanding the critically devastating consequences. This was supported in as far back as 1968 in a study by Matthew.

In 1968, Victor Matthews conducted a study among a group of high school students (boys) in the mid-west. He utilized two instruments, a personal data sheet and a delinquency scale similar to the one used by Short. The emphasis in the study was on the degree of delinquent involvement by an individual as compared to that of his peers. In his study. Matthews found that uniformity in behavior was greatest between best friends; individuals who shred ideas, thoughts, activities, and time together in similar environments. He concluded that the greater the degree of identification between individuals, the greater will be the degree of uniformity of their self-reported behaviors.  Again, the theory of Differential Association was supported by the results of his study (Mathews, 1968).
                                                                    References
Lilly, J., Cullen, F., & .Ball, R (1995). Criminological theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Moon, B., Hwang, H. W., and McCluskey, J. D. (2011). “Causes of school bullying: empirical test of a general theory of crime, differential association theory, and general strain theory,” Crime and Delinquency, 57(6), pp. 849–877.
Pfohl, S. (1994). Images of Deviance and Social Control. McGraw-Hill, Inc.
Sutherland, E.H. (1974). Criminology. J.B. Lippincott Company.Matthews, V. (1968). Differential identification: An empirical note, Social Problems, 1, 383.

Social Learning Theory and Its Connection to Juvenile Delinquency and Bullying

Social Learning Theory and Its Connection to Juvenile Delinquency and Bullying

By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
 A question that is asked constantly in today’s society by much of society to psychologist, sociologists, criminologists and to just about anyone who will stop and listen is “why do people act the way they do today and how did some of the people who are committing crimes and heinous crimes today learn to act the way they do; what caused this to occur?” and the answer to this is not that difficult. At the moment of birth we begin to be socialized and this process teaches us how to act and respond to various events that we are exposed to in our lives. If one takes the time to look at thirty, forty or sixty years ago it is obvious that the values, norms, and mores were very different at that time. The issue here is that society has developed and made major achievements and progress in rights and the dignity of many groups of people in society.  The problem is that some people can handle certain rights and some people become somewhat drunk with the new found rights and decide to take things too far and create a negative environment. It has been this way throughout history and it is evidenced by the fact that there have been and always will be individuals in society that will break the law due to them not having a well-functioning inner governor on their actions and ignore the outer governors that exist in society to assist in maintaining social control and stability in society. Once negative behavior has been learned and then reinforced the rationale decision making now is skewed and the results are egotistical and narcissistic self- satiation and instant gratification at others expenses. Power and control are two of the methods sought out in one’s quest in obtaining this self-satisfaction.

People learn behavior via observation, acting out the behavior, and then being rewarded by successfully accomplishing the reenactment of the behavior (Bandura, 1986, 1997, 2001). When learned behavior is positively reinforced, whether it is socially acceptable or unacceptable, it is something that will continue until the individual feels it is no longer a benefit to them or it stops being reinforced by those around them who value their recognition. The more value a person places on the approval of their actions the more solidified the learning becomes and the stronger the desire and need becomes to perform that learned behavior. Learning theories tend to follow the lead of Edwin Sutherland's theory of differential association, developed in 1947, although ideas about imitation or modeling go back to 1890.  Often oversimplified as "peer group" theories, learning is much more than that, and involves the analysis of what is positively and negatively rewarding (reinforcing) for individuals (Williams & McShane, 1998). This type of learning is directly applicable to all types of learning to include positive activities such as learning how to prosecute. This was demonstrated in a study by Barone (2013) wherein he demonstrated that new female prosecutors learned how to prosecute by observing other prosecutors due to the fact that there are no courses in Florida for new prosecutors to learn their tradecraft.

Social learning theory (Bandura, 1963, 1997, 2011), Rotter (1981, 1982), and Differential Association created by Sutherland (1974) were created and geared toward the explanation of the commission of crimes by youth which supports what is posited by Blumstein, Cohen, Roth, & Visher (1986) and Baker (1998) and relates directly to school violence which is perpetrated by children of varying ages. These theorists advised that males are more likely to commit crimes than females, and this is especially true when discussing serious crimes. These authors also advised that the commission of crime is pre-eminently a preoccupation of the young, whether male or female, which is also borne out by the findings of the two studies conducted for this research from both law enforcement agencies. Hirschi (1969) advised that crime is overwhelmingly committed by people in the age range 15-24 and with this information we would expect crime to increase with the number of people in this population age range which has been demonstrated in the past decade with the various types of school violence which has transpired.

When performing research in the area of violence there are a number of theories which deal with aggression resulting in the manifestation of violence. The use of social learning theory, which is a component of social process theory, to explain and help to understand the violent behaviors of children perpetrating school violence will assist in providing an explanation for aggressive behavior. Social learning theory can also be used to provide an understanding of why children commit school shootings and even serial killings. It can be used to examine thoroughly the child’s childhood experiences and what they have been exposed to during those formative years which in the majority of cases holds the answers to the manifestation of their inner frustrations and to strike out in an attempt to regain their power, control and legitimization (Bandura, 1973). Special attention should be given by those investigating and also researching violent events by children to childhood experiences with specified attention being paid to evidence of victimization or the witnessing of violent behavior. The behavior being looked for would be similar to that which is being exhibited by the child. Bandura and Walters (1959, 1963) advised that boys who were demonstrating particularly aggressive behavior and who were also acting in an antagonistic and hostile manner had experienced feelings of rejection by their fathers during their childhood. In a study performed by Brown (1984) expressed that abuse and emotional neglectwere correlated with various forms of reported delinquency. In her book Sins of Fathers (1978), Ruth Inglis notes that there is a strong relationship between children who are or have been abused and subsequent violent behavior Inglis (1978). In keeping with the foundations of social learning theory it must be understood and remembered that a child does not have to have been a victim of violence and abuse; they can also be an observer and learn the behavior from that exposure (Hickey, 2013).

                                                             References
Bandura, A. (1973). Aggression. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Bandura, A. (1986). Social Foundations of Thought and Action. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-            Hall.
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. New York: W.H. Freeman.
Bandura, A. (2001). Social cognitive theory: An agentive perspective. Annual Review of Psychology, 52, 1-26.Rondal Press.
Bandura, A., & Walters, R. H. (1959). Adolescent Aggression. New York NY: Ronald Press.
Bandura, A. and Walters, R. H. (1963). Social Learning and Personality Development. New York: Colt, Rinehart, and Winston.
Barone, P.A. (2013). Plea Bargaining: The Lived Experience of Female Prosecutorial Discretion and Decision Making. (Doctoral Dissertation). Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses. (Accession Order No. AAT 3411606)
Blumstein, A.J., Cohen, J., Roth, and Visher, C.A. (1986). Criminal careers and “career criminals”. Washington, DC: National Academy Pres.
Hickey, E. W. (2013). Serial murders and their victims. 6th ed. Belmont, CA; Wadsworth.
Hirschi, T. (1969). Causes of Delinquency. Berkley CA: University of California Press.
Inglis, R. (1978). Sins of Father: A study of the Physical and Emotional Abuse of Children. New York: St. Martin’s Press. 
Rotter, J. B. (1981). The psychological situation in social learning theory. In D. Magnusson (Ed.), Toward a psychology of situations: An interactional perspective. Hillsdale, NJ:                        Lawrence Erlbaum.
Rotter, J. B. (1982). The development and applications of social learning theory. New York:
                      Praeger.
Sutherland, E.H. (1974). Criminology. J.B. Lippincott Company.
Williams, H. and McShane, M. D. (2010).  Criminological Theory 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

 

Saturday, January 16, 2016

Understanding the Evidentiary Aspects of The Proper Procedures for Executing a Warrant and Testifying to Law Enforcement Actions


The Proper Procedures for Executing a Warrant and Testifying to Law Enforcement Actions
BY: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
When executing a Warrant to Search to Seize property or an Arrest Warrant to Seize a Person  the law enforcement official(s) need to make sure that they document everything that is done on the scene so it can be testified to in a criminal proceeding or criminal trial. This information will be examined and scrutinized by the defense attorney in all criminal cases.
Understanding the various issues and aspects of obtaining, executing, performing an inventory, creating property receipts, and accomplishing the return of the warrant and the accompanying forms will provide the  law enforcement officer with the ability to better provide valuable testimony when the defense attempts to suppress it and the prosecution tries to have it admitted.
Noting the Date, Time and Location
The officer executing the warrant must enter on it the exact date and time it was executed and any and all documentation regarding the day, time, and location of the execution is critical and will definitely be a point of in depth examination by defense attorneys. It must be remembered that any discrepancy here will provide the defense with a window into attacking the law enforcement official’s case and the prosecutor’s case.

Inventory
An officer present during the execution of the warrant must prepare and verify an inventory of any property seized. The officer must do so in the presence of another officer and the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken. If either one is not present, the officer must prepare and verify the inventory in the presence of at least one other credible person. In a case involving the seizure of electronic storage media or the seizure or copying of electronically stored information, the inventory may be limited to describing the physical storage media that were seized or copied. The officer may retain a copy of the electronically stored information that was seized or copied. This inventory must be accomplished in the most perfect and accurate manner. If one item is not memorialized properly it will be the beginning of the point of exploiting the entire execution of the warrant and the collection of evidence.

Reciept
The officer executing the warrant must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken or leave a copy of the warrant and receipt at the place where the officer took the property. Again, like the inventory the property receipt must be accomplished in the most perfect and accurate manner. If one item is not memorialized properly it will be the beginning of the point of exploiting the entire execution of the warrant and the collection of evidence.
Return
The officer executing the warrant must promptly return it together with a copy of the inventory to the magistrate or the judge designated on the warrant. The officer may do so by reliable electronic means if the agency has the ability and the court allows for this method. The judge must, on request, give a copy of the inventory to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken and to the applicant for the warrant. Again, like the inventory and the property receipt the return must be accomplished in the most perfect and accurate manner. If one item is not memorialized properly it will be the beginning of the point of exploiting the entire execution of the warrant and the collection of evidence.
This is How the Court Decides Whether Law Enforcement Actions Violated the Fourth Amendment
In general, a court will ask two questions to conclude whether a police investigation turned into a search and if it was conducted in a legal manner. The court will first to ask if the person whose home or property were being investigated/searched expected a degree of privacy. Second the court will then ask if that expectation of privacy was reasonable. The question is answered in the light of society, meaning the question revolves around whether society would recognize some sort of privacy in the matter in question. To have an investigation to turn into a search, a court must conclude that the investigation impinged or intruded upon a person's "legitimate expectation of privacy." An intrusion into a person’s legitimate expectation of privacy is found when the answer to the above two questions is yes. If either question can be answered in the negative, meaning that the person being search either did not have something to keep private, or if the expectation of privacy was not reasonable, then there was no search. The law enforcement officers are going to have to provide testimonial evidence during a hearing for the judge to make the proper informed decision regarding this issue. The best way to avoid the uncomfortable feeling of being in one of these hearings is to obtain an arrest or search warrant prior to taking the searching action.
 

Exculpatory and Inculpatory Evidence and the Importance of Each in a Criminal Trial


Exculpatory and Inculpatory Evidence and the Importance of Each in a Criminal Trial

BY: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

Exculpatory Evidence
The Brady Rule, named for Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), requires prosecutors to disclose materially exculpatory evidence the government's possession to the defense. "Brady material" or evidence the prosecutor is required to disclose under this rule includes any evidence favorable to the accused which is seen to be evidence that goes towards negating a defendant's guilt, that would reduce a defendant's potential sentence, or evidence going to the credibility of a witness. 

When addressing some evidence that could be introduced into a criminal evidence which is labelled to be “Exculpatory Evidence” is evidence that indicates the defendant did not commit the crime he has been accused of.  Exculpatory evidence is exactly opposite of what is known as  “inculpatory evidence. Inculpatory evidence is that which is considered to be evidence that indicates the defendant did actually commit the crime he or she was charged with committing.  When there is some type of evidence that is neither exculpatory nor inculpatory this type of evidence is likely to be excluded from court as irrelevant, because it doesn’t support either side’s arguments and to be allowed into a criminal proceeding or a criminal trial it must be relevant and material to some issue in the case.  
In the case of Brady v. Maryland, the U.S. Supreme Court held that if a prosecutor has access to exculpatory evidence, he is required to share that evidence with the defense.  In addition, failing to disclose the information to the defense may result in the case being thrown out in a motion to dismiss, as a mistrial, or being overturned on an appeal.  The Supreme Court based this ruling on the Constitution’s due process clauses wherein it held that part of a prosecutor’s responsibility to seek justice is to make sure that all evidence, not just evidence that supports the prosecutor’s case, is available at trial for review and assessment by the judge in a bench trial and the jury in a jury trial. 
If the prosecution does not disclose material exculpatory evidence under this rule, and prejudice has ensued, the evidence will be suppressed. In fact if the prosecutor does not reveal the exculpatory evidence the evidence will be suppressed regardless of whether the prosecutor knew the evidence was in his or her possession, or whether or not the prosecutor intentionally or inadvertently withheld the evidence from the defense. The defendant bears the burden of proving that the undisclosed evidence was material, and the defendant must show that there is a reasonable probability that there would be a difference in the outcome of the trial had the evidence been disclosed by the prosecutor. This is considered to be evidence such as a statement, tending to excuse, justify, or absolve the alleged fault or guilt of a defendant.       
Inculpatory Evidence
When discussing evidence which is known as Inculpatory Evidence it is understood that this is evidence that establish the guilt of an accused. This type of evidence indicates that a defendant committed a crime. Inculpatory evidence also shows, or tends to show, the criminal defendant's involvement in the criminal act which the defendant has been charged with in the criminal trial.  In criminal law, evidence that favors the prosecution's case is called the inculpatory evidence and this type of evidence is the opposite of what is known as exculpatory evidence, which indicates the innocence of the accused.

Example
If a man is stabbed to death by a knife and if that particular knife is then found in possession of the individual’s wife. When this particular knife is located this knife will be considered as inculpatory evidence against the wife.

This type of evidence, inculpatory evidence, is critical for the prosecution of a criminal defendant due to the fact that in a criminal case in the United States the prosecutor has the complete burden of proving each and every single element of the crimes that the defendant has been charged with in a criminal trial. This is the exact type of evidence that is needed by the prosecution to accomplished their goals and objectives of the burden of proof.

                                                         Reference
Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963).

Friday, January 15, 2016

Understanding Negative Evidence versus Positive Evidence


Understanding Negative Evidence versus Positive Evidence

BY: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

Relevant evidence encompasses evidence tending to establish negative facts as well as positive ones. Negative testimony is admissible, if the attending circumstances indicate that it has some probative force, such as concerning what the witness did not see or did not hear, but a witness may not testify to the nonexistence of a fact where the fact might have existed without the person being aware of it. Basically Negative Evidence is known as testimony that an alleged fact did  not exist.  Negative evidence is admissible when a qualified person, who has examined certain records or documents, testifies that he or she did not find any reference to or entry of a particular item or transaction.

To better understand the concept of positive versus negative evidence an explanation of what positive evidence is can assist with this explanation. Evidence is considered to be Positive Evidence when a witness is testifying and during the testimony they are able to state that a certain thing or event either did or did not occur or exist, and evidence is considered to be negative energy when the witness states that he or she did not see of know of the existence of a certain circumstance of fact (Klotter, 2012).

This does not mean, however, that relevant evidence should always presented in an affirmative form. Negative testimony is admissible if the attendant circumstances show that it has some probative force, and the competency of the witness, and his or her knowledge of the matter of which he or she speaks are established.

There are several cases which have provided examples regarding of negative evidence.
1978 Norfolk & W. Ry. v. Greenfield, 219 Va. 122, 244 S.E.2d 781 (1978).
Positive testimony of single witness, whose credibility is unimpeached, that he saw or heard particular thing at particular time or place ordinarily outweighs as matter of law testimony of any number of credible witnesses who, with same opportunity, say that they did not see or hear it. If there is evidence that one who denies fact had good opportunity to see or hear, and evidence demonstrates that he probably would have seen or heard event if it had occurred, then such evidence produces conflict in evidence to be decided by trier of fact.
1976 Bunn v. Norfolk, F. & D. Ry., 217 Va. 45, 225 S.E.2d 375 (1976).
Positive testimony outweighs negative equally credible testimony. Opportunity of witness to hear railroad signals was limited.

1973 Mitchell v. Lee, 213 Va. 629, 194 S.E.2d 737 (1973).
Plaintiff’s testimony that she did not see sign is merely negative testimony and is indicative of fact that she was not keeping proper lookout.

1968 National Union Fire Ins. v. Bruce, 208 Va. 595, 159 S.E.2d 815 (1968).
Positive testimony of credible witness ordinarily outweighs negative evidence of number of witnesses. But this rule does not always apply where one witness says he did not see that which another says did occur. If there is evidence that witness had good opportunity to see and that he probably would have seen it if it had occurred or that his attention was drawn to situation, then his testimony is positive and not negative.

1965 Skinner v. Norfolk & W. Ry., 206 Va. 649, 145 S.E.2d 170 (1965).
Railroad crossing accident. Witnesses testified they did not hear train signals. This negative evidence must be evaluated in light of fact that their opportunity to hear was limited and their attention was diverted by other matters.

1959 Norfolk & W. Ry. v. Sykes, 200 Va. 541, 106 S.E.2d 734 (1959).
Positive testimony ordinarily outweighs that of number of other witnesses, equally credible, who with same opportunities testify merely that they did not see or hear thing in question.

1958 Railway Co. v. Barden, 200 Va. 98, 104 S.E.2d 13 (1958).
Positive testimony of credible witness who testifies, that he saw or heard particular thing at particular time, ordinarily outweighs that of number of other witnesses equally credible who with same opportunity testify merely that they did not see or hear it.

1955 Chesapeake & O. Ry. v. Hanes, 196 Va. 806, 86 S.E.2d 122 (1955).
Where witness testifies that he did not hear train signals, this may not be disregarded as purely negative in character and devoid of probative value where conditions are such that he probably would have heard them.

1953 Bangley v. Virginian Ry., 195 Va. 340, 78 S.E.2d 696 (1953).
Jury properly instructed that “the testimony of a witness that he did not hear a whistle blow or a bell ring is not entitled to the same weight” as positive testimony of one who says that whistle and bell were sounded, unless it appears that former had as good opportunity to hear whistle and bell, and that it is probable that he would have heard them.

Although a foundation must be laid before negative testimony is relevant and competent, testimony as to the nonexistence of a fact or as to the witness’ lack of knowledge of its existence is admissible where the situation of the witness was such that if the fact had existed, he or she probably would have known it. Some of the legal scholars and judges regard negative evidence as having less weight than positive evidence and while it is considered to be valuable and admissible when proper foundation has been laid, provided that the competency of the witness and his or her knowledge of the matter are established (Klotter, 2000).
                                                          Reference
Klotter, J. C. (2012). Criminal Evidence 11th ed. Boca Raton, FL: Taylor and Francis Publishing.
Chesapeake & O. Ry. v. Hanes, 196 Va. 806, 86 S.E.2d 122 (1955).
Bunn v. Norfolk, F. & D. Ry., 217 Va. 45, 225 S.E.2d 375 (1976).
Chesapeake & O. Ry. v. Hanes, 196 Va. 806, 86 S.E.2d 122 (1955).
Mitchell v. Lee, 213 Va. 629, 194 S.E.2d 737 (1973).
National Union Fire Ins. v. Bruce, 208 Va. 595, 159 S.E.2d 815 (1968).
Norfolk & W. Ry. v. Greenfield, 219 Va. 122, 244 S.E.2d 781 (1978).
Norfolk & W. Ry. v. Sykes, 200 Va. 541, 106 S.E.2d 734 (1959).
Railway Co. v. Barden, 200 Va. 98, 104 S.E.2d 13 (1958).
Skinner v. Norfolk & W. Ry., 206 Va. 649, 145 S.E.2d 170 (1965).
 

 

 

Thursday, January 14, 2016

United States Supreme Court Decision Regarding the Legality of the Death Penalty and the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution


United States Supreme Court Decision Regarding the Legality of the Death Penalty and the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution

By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

The United Supreme Court has made and rendered a decision regarding the actual decision making process of how a criminal defendant in a case where they are facing the death penalty. This case and decision is not the usual objections to the death penalty which is usually brought under the Eight Amendment of the United States Constitution due to the cruel and unusual manner in which the death penalty is administered in its actually execution of the condemned defendant.

This issue was demonstrated in the case of March 25, 1997. Florida. Pedro The electrocution of death row inmate Pedro Medina was a horrific example of an electrocution gone horribly wrong. During this electrocution a crown of foot-high flames shot from the inmate’s headpiece during the actual execution, filling the execution chamber with a stench of thick smoke and gagging the two dozen official witnesses. An official then threw a switch to manually cut off the power and prematurely end the two-minute cycle of 2,000 volts. Medina's chest continued to heave until the flames stopped and death came.  After the execution, prison officials blamed the fire on a corroded copper screen in the headpiece of the electric chair, but two experts hired by the governor later concluded that the fire was caused by the improper application of a sponge which was specifically designed to conduct electricity to Medina's head during the electrocution (Martin, 1997).

The defendant has the right to have the jury make the decision as to the defendant’s fate of life in prison or the death penalty. There is a bifurcation in First Degree Murder case is provided for a specific reason which is for the jury to determine guilty, which they must do before the second part of the trial can occur. In a non-death penalty case there is a decision by the jury and the judge makes the decision as to what sentence a person would be given after being convicted. According to the United States Supreme Court the current scheme that the State of Florida uses to sentence people to die is consider to be unconstitutional and this is according to an 8-1 decision handed down by the Supreme Court on Tuesday January 12, 2016.

In the Supreme Court’s decision, looking at the overall situation as a matter of legal doctrine, Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s opinion for the Court in Hurst v. Florida (2016) is not particularly surprising. However, there’s also some uncertainty about just how far this case will go to disrupt the death penalty in Florida. Nevertheless, this particular decision, which was made by the United States Supreme Court is considered to be a victory for the opponents of the death penalty and this decision was handed down just months after the Court took an aggressively pro-execution stance last summer. In this decision there was only one justice dissenting which was Justice Samuel Alito.

The examination of this particular case demonstrates that the case did involve an unusual scheme which the State of Florida uses after someone has been convicted of a crime that can potentially carry the death penalty. Like all death penalty trials in the United States, Florida divides those trials into one phase to determine if a defendant is guilty and another to determine if they should be executed. In Florida, however, the jury only renders an “advisory sentence” during the penalty phase of the trial, and the ultimate sentence is determined based on factual findings by the judge and not the jury.

This process, with the judge making the decision of the sentence of life in prison or the death penalty, is what is not what the Sixth Amendment requires. As the Court and the Justices advise that this particular process actually violates the Sixth Amendment’s command that in all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury and with the judge making the final decision regarding the death penalty that is not what the Sixth Amendment requires. In fact this exact situation was decided in another case. The Supreme Court already held in the case of Ring v. Arizona (2002) that a similar death penalty sentencing scheme in Arizona also violates the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution. Again, in the Arizona case it was the Sixth Amendment and not the Eight Amendment that was being violated.  

In a 7-2 decision in the case of Ring v. Arizona, (2002) the U.S. Supreme Court held that a defendant has the right to have a jury, rather than a judge, decide on the existence of an aggravating factor that makes the defendant eligible for the death penalty. In its decision, the Court held that a death sentence where the necessary aggravating factors are determined by a judge violates a defendant's constitutional right to a trial by jury.

The existing question that is being addressed at this time is what, if any type of an impact will the Hurst v. Florida (2016) decision have on other inmates currently sitting on Florida’s death row. Two years after Ring, the justices held that its Arizona decision was not retroactive to inmates whose sentences were locked in prior to the day Ring was handed down. This may suggest that most of the existing Florida death row inmates will not be able to take advantage of the Hurst decision. At the same time, however, Hurst does little more than track the Court’s 2002 decision in Ring, suggesting that inmates whose sentences were finalized after 2002 should benefit from the Court’s decision in Hurst. One issue is that the Florida Supreme Court “employs a retroactivity doctrine that is broader than” the federal rule, with this situation it is possible that Hurst decision could apply to the entire state’s death row and this will be something that will be addressed in the near future.

                                                                  References
Martin, D. (1997 March 26). Flames Erupt from Killer's Headpiece. The Gainesville Sun.   
Hurst v. Florida, (2016).
Ring v. Arizona, (2002).

 

Wednesday, January 13, 2016

Baltimore Officer Porter's Appeal Fifth Amendment Versus Immunity: A True Constitutional Challenge


Baltimore Officer Porter’s Case Involving the Debate Between the Fifth Amendment and Granting of Immunity to Testify as a Witness While Being a Defendant in the Same Case

BY: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq. 

Under the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution, a person may not be compelled to testify against himself. The prosecution may require a witness to testify, but to do so, must first confer immunity upon the witness. Immunity from prosecution may be granted by the prosecutor at several stages in the criminal process. The prosecutor can grant a witness immunity at the grand jury stage and then at any other stage of the criminal process or proceedings and this is usually done at the trial stage of the process. The interesting challenge here is that the witness is also a defendant in the very same case. When discussing Immunity it must be understood that there are two types of prosecutorial immunity that apply during the criminal process. 
Different Types of Immunity 

There are two types of immunity that are at the disposal of the prosecutor which can be used in a case prior to the case actually getting into the court room and the judge getting involved with the process. The first type of immunity is known as "Transactional immunity" which is a very broad type of immunity.  A person who is a witness and who have been given transactional immunity cannot be prosecuted for the underlying offense; however, if during their testimony if they lie or misrepresent information during their testimony under oath they can be prosecuted for the crime or perjury. This type of immunity is rarely given in a criminal case unless the person has a vast amount of unbelievable information that they can testify to in a very major case.

There is a second type of immunity, and the most used in criminal cases by prosecutors, is known as Use Immunity. When discussing use immunity and comparing and contrasting them there is a difference in the fact that use immunity is narrower in its nature and scope.  In use immunity the statements made by the witness may not be used against the witness; however, the prosecution does not agree that it will never prosecute the person for the crime but cannot use their testimony to prosecute them. With this type of immunity the witness may actually be prosecuted at a later time based upon independent and untainted evidence. In addition, the immunity is only valid in the jurisdiction of that state and not in a federal proceeding or a civil proceeding that may be pending or may be created due to the witness’s statement while under the limited cloak of immunity (Scheb & Scheb, 2008).  

There is also Use and Transactional Immunity at the Federal court level. The United States can compel testimony from an unwilling witness who invokes the Fifth Amendment privilege against compulsory self-incrimination by conferring immunity, as provided by 18 U,S,C, 6002, from use of the compelled testimony and evidence derived therefrom in subsequent criminal proceedings, as such immunity from use and derivative use is coextensive with the scope of the privilege and is sufficient to compel testimony over a claim of the privilege. Transactional immunity would afford broader protection than the Fifth Amendment privilege, and is not constitutionally required.  

In both the state and federal systems the prosecution must meet a burden that does not include using the information from the immunity to bring a case against the witnesses who testified with the granted immunity. Therefore in any subsequent criminal prosecution, the prosecution has the burden of proving affirmatively that evidence proposed to be used is derived from a legitimate source wholly independent of the compelled testimony.

A witness given use immunity may not be forced to testify and may assert the privilege against self-incrimination People v Kramer, 123 AD2d 786 (2d Dept 1986). 

Witness Invoking Self-incrimination Right at Trial

In Kastigar v. United States 406 US 441 (1972) the Court addressed the issues as to whether testimony may be compelled by granting immunity from the use of compelled testimony and evidence derived therefrom ('use and derivative use' immunity), or whether it is necessary to grant immunity from prosecution for offenses to which compelled testimony relates ('transactional' immunity'). In Kastigar v. United States (1972) the Court affirmed and advised that the decision made by the lower court were correct that the proper form of immunity in such cases is "use and derivative use" immunity.
"The statute's explicit proscription of the use in any criminal case of 'testimony or other information compelled under the order (or any information directly or indirectly derived from such testimony or other information)' is consonant with Fifth Amendment standards. We hold that such immunity from use and derivative use is coextensive with the scope of the privilege against self-incrimination, and therefore is sufficient to compel testimony over a claim of the privilege" Kastigar v United States (p. 453 1972). The Court here felt that Transactional Immunity, which accords full immunity from prosecution for the offense to which the compelled testimony relates, affords the witness considerably broader protection than does the Fifth Amendment privilege" Kastigar v. United States (p. 453 1972).
The Court also advised that "There can be no justification in reason or policy for holding that the Constitution requires an amnesty grant where, acting pursuant to statute and accompanying safeguards, testimony is compelled in exchange for immunity from use and derivative use when no such amnesty is required where the government, acting without colorable right, coerces a defendant into incriminating himself" Kastigar v. United States (p. (462 1972). In this case the petitioner wanted the court to grand transactional (full) immunity. In the case of the Officer Porter it appears that this would be the most proper avenue to take since he is not just a witness in this case but a co-defendant. 

Baltimore Police Officer Porter Invoking Fifth Amendment Right to Not Testify as Witness Against Co-Defendant

The issue in the instant case in Baltimore is that the witness being compelled here is already on trial for participating in the same transaction and occurrence and places a different twist on this issue at hand. The Court’s reasoning is that in any usual case when a witness is called they can take the Fifth Amendment and then be provided with use immunity. However, here with Officer Porter, he is not just a witness he is also a defendant in the same case.

Prior to the United States Supreme Court’s decision  in the Kastigar v. United States (1972)the guiding legal precedent was the case of Counselman v. Hitchcock  142 U.S. 547 (1892), which provided for full "transactional" immunity in cases of compelled statements which is similar to the issue which is being addressed in the Baltimore Police Officers case involving Officer Porter.  As was previously stated when dealing with "Transactional" immunity this means that the individual who is testifying has full protection from prosecution for the offense under investigation.   The situation changed with the Court’s decision in Kastigar, in which the Supreme Court overturned Counselman, and they then held that immunity for compelled statements only applies to the use of the statements themselves, and to any evidence gained as a result of the protected statements.  
This is known as "use and derivative use" immunity, in which "use" is the use of the protected statements, and "derivative use" pertains to any evidence gained as a result of the protected statements.  It is also known as "use plus fruits" immunity. This means that the person in question can still be prosecuted for the offense under investigation, as long as the prosecution relies solely on evidence other than the protected statements and their fruits. However, information from the statements and information presented during the testimony can be the guiding light use to uncover and discover the proof needed to further investigate and charge the witness as a defendant.
In the Baltimore’s Officer Porter’s case he is already a defendant in the same transactions and occurrence he is being compelled to testify in with use immunity. In addition, he was already tried which resulted in a mistrial and the prosecution is could obtain information from his testifying that they would not have been privy to due to him invoking his Fifth Amendment Right to remain silent and through the use of the use immunity the prosecution can circumvent this right which is one of the bedrocks of our Due Process.

The result is that in many cases, what is known as a "Kastigar Hearing" takes place, in which the prosecution must prove that its case rests solely on evidence other than the protected statements and their fruits. This was of more recent significance in regard to the Nisour Square incident of September 16, 2007.  On that day, Blackwater military contractors in Iraq killed 17 civilians in Baghdad's Nisour Square.  In December 2008 the United States Department of Justice brought criminal charges against five of the contractors who'd been involved, but the charges were dismissed in late 2009 because the prosecution had utilized evidence that was gained as a result of compelled statements by the employees.
This is a real challenge to the rationale involving use and transactional immunity in relation to the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution. No matter which immunity is offered or used involving Officer Porter the information provided from his testimony, after invoking his Fifth Amendment Right first as a subject and then as a defendant, along with his mandate to give a statement under Garrity, provided and will provide for a second time a chance at information that should not be legally accessible under  our Due Process System when the Fifth Amendment is invoked by a defendant and if it does it will open a very large hole in the protection of the Fifth Amendment for anyone else finding themselves in this position.
                                                               References
Counselman v. Hitchcock, 142 U.S. 547 (1892).
Kastigar v. United States, 406 US 441 (1972).
Garrity v. New Jersey, 385 U.S. 493 (1967).
Scheb, J.M. and, Scheb, J.M., (2008) Criminal Law and Procedure 7th ed. Belmont, CA: Cengage Publishing.