Sunday, January 10, 2016

Understanding the Preemptory Challenges During the Jury Selection Process Which was the Basis for the Reversal of the Dalia Dippolito Case


Understanding the Preemptory Challenges During the Jury Selection Process Which was the Basis for the Reversal of the Dalia Dippolito Case
By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
In the case of Dalia Dippolito she was convicted of solicitation to commit first-degree murder in 2011, but the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed the conviction last year. A Palm Beach County judge Thursday set her retrial for May 23. The judge has advised that the defense attorney and the prosecution have opportunities to examine each of the potential jurors to make a determination if the potential jurors are going to be able to be good jurors in this particular case. One of the most important things that both sides look for, this is especially true when the case is a prominent or publicized case like this one, is to determine if there are potential jurors in the pool being examined who have heard or observed or have been exposed to a great deal of information pertaining to the case. This is done in an attempt to determine any of the potential jurors have come to the trial with preconceptions of the defendant being either guilty or not guilty of the crime prior to hearing the legally admitted evidence presented by the prosecution and the defense. This is what was not done in the first jury selection process and caused the reversal.

There are a couple of ways in which attorneys exercise the right to challenge a juror without assigning, or being required to assign, a reason for the challenge. This type of challenge is one in which the attorney’s do not have to provide a reason or cause for wanting to not allow a juror to sit on this jury and there are a certain number of these challenges. The second type of challenge that is used during the selection of a jury again can be used by both parties during the proceedings where they may challenge prospective jurors for a lack of impartiality, known as a challenge for cause. A party may challenge an unlimited number of prospective jurors for cause.

Peremptory challenges provide a more impartial and better qualified jury. Peremptory challenges allow an attorney to reject a potential juror for real or imagined partiality that would be difficult to demonstrate under the challenge for cause category. These challenges, however, have become more difficult to exercise because the U.S. Supreme Court has forbidden peremptory strikes based on race or gender.

When dealing with preemptory challenges in a jury selection process it is understood that the parties do not have a federal constitutional right to exercise peremptory challenges. Peremptory challenges are granted by statute or by case law and the actual number of preemptory challenges is usually determined by statute; however, there are some jurisdictions which allow the trial court to grant additional peremptory challenges. In federal court each side is entitled to three peremptory challenges and if more than two parties are involved in the proceeding, the court may either grant additional challenges or restrict the parties to the minimum number of challenges.

Peremptory challenges came under legal attack in the 1980s where several critics claimed that white prosecutors used their peremptory challenges to remove African Americans from the jury when the criminal defendant was also African American because the prosecutors thought that the potential jurors would be sympathetic to a member of their own race.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712, 90 L. Ed. 2d 69 (1986), prohibited prosecutors from excluding prospective jurors on the basis of race. Under the Batson test, a defendant may object to a prosecutor's peremptory challenge. The prosecutor then must "come forward with a neutral explanation for challenging black jurors." If the prosecutor cannot offer a neutral explanation, the court will not excuse the juror and this applies to blacks, whites, Hispanics, Asians, females and males.

The Court extended this holding in criminal proceedings in two later cases. In the case of Powers v. Ohio, 499 U.S. 400, 111 S. Ct. 1364, 113 L. Ed. 2d 411 (1991), the Court broadened the Batson rule by stating that a defendant need not be of the same race as the excluded juror in order to successfully challenge the juror's exclusion. In another case, Georgia v. McCollum, 505 U.S. 42, 112 S. Ct. 2348, 120 L. Ed. 2d 33 (1992), the Court held that the defense's exercise of peremptory challenges to strike African American jurors on the basis of their race was equally forbidden. Previously, the court had ruled in Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete Co., 500 U.S. 614, 111 S. Ct. 2077, 114 L. Ed. 2d 660 (1991), that in civil trials a private party could not exclude prospective jurors on account of their race by using peremptory challenges. This series of decisions makes any racial exclusion in jury selection constitutionally suspect. These cases demonstrate how important it is to make the jury selection process fair and free from discrimination which includes prospective jurors having been exposed to positive or negative information pertaining to the case and defendant that would have an impact on fairness.

In the United States of America the Supreme Court has also specifically forbidden peremptory challenges based on gender. In J. E. B. v. Alabama, 511 U.S. 127, 114 S. Ct. 1419, 128 L. Ed. 2d 89 (1994), the Court ruled that striking jurors on the basis of gender serves to perpetuate stereotypes that are prejudicial and based on historical discrimination. No overriding State Interest can justify peremptory challenges on the basis of gender. Permitting gender-based strikes could also have undermined the Batson holding, because gender might be used as an excuse for racial discrimination so again the court is seeking fairness trying to make the entire process a fair one. This was not done in the jury selection in the case of Dalia Dippolito and that is why the appellate court reversed the decision in that case.
In an extension of Batson, the Supreme Court of Connecticut ruled that the Equal Protection Clause barred the prosecutor from striking prospective jurors based on their religious affiliation. The court, in State v. Hodge, 726 A.2d 531 (Conn.1999), distinguished religious beliefs and religious affiliations. It held that litigants could strike prospective jurors whose religious beliefs would prevent them from performing their duties as jurors.
                                                       References
Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79, 106 S. Ct. 1712, 90 L. Ed. 2d 69 (1986).
Edmonson v. Leesville Concrete Co., 500 U.S. 614, 111 S. Ct. 2077, 114 L. Ed. 2d 660 (1991).
Georgia v. McCollum, 505 U.S. 42, 112 S. Ct. 2348, 120 L. Ed. 2d 33 (1992).
J. E. B. v. Alabama, 511 U.S. 127, 114 S. Ct. 1419, 128 L. Ed. 2d 89 (1994).
Powers v. Ohio, 499 U.S. 400, 111 S. Ct. 1364, 113 L. Ed. 2d 411 (1991).
State v. Hodge, 726 A.2d 531 (Conn.1999).

 
The Dippolito Contract Murder Case and Change of Venue

By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
A serious mistake made by the Circuit Court Judge during the Jury Selection process in the attempted Murder for Hire case in the State of Florida in 2009 of Dalia Dipplolito

In its opinion, the appellate court deemed that the trial court erred by denying her request to individually
question prospective jurors about their exposure to pretrial publicity about her case and denying her request to strike the entire jury pool after all the jurors heard an allegation that Dippolito had attempted to poison her husband.

Dippolito was arrested in August 2009 after she hired an undercover police officer who was posing as a hit man to kill her husband, Michael Dippolito. Police then staged a crime scene and recorded her reaction on the day the murder was supposed to take place.
Jurors during the trial were shown an undercover video of Dalia Dippolito offering an undercover officer pretending to be a hit man $5,000 to kill her husband.

In the United States Jury System the selection of a jury is critical to the outcome of the case for both the defense and prosecution. In the book I am writing I provide the history of evidence and how thousands of years ago the jurors were selected on what they actually did know about the case. However, I also present that today we have come full circle and we do not want any of the jurors to have detailed information or an opinion about the case, the defendant and guilt or innocence. We want the jurors to be like a completely clean white board and the only things we want the jurors to know, understand and consider in their deliberation process is what has been admitted by the court.
The selection of potential jurors is a critical stage and the ability to ask them about their exposure to pretrial publicity is critical to trying to understand whether each potential juror will or will not be struck with either a preemptory strike or a strike for cause.
If it is determined that so many people have a great deal of pretrial publicity about the case at hand. If it is determined, and in this case was determined that just about every juror has a good deal of knowledge regarding the case and with this demonstrated a motion for Change of Venue will be made.
A change of venue in the criminal law system is something that occurs when the defense shows that there is a reasonable likelihood that the defendant can’t receive a fair trial in the current court. Events that make it nearly impossible to find an impartial jury justify venue change. The most prevalent of these events is pretrial publicity as we have in the instant case regarding the defendant Dippolito. Some cases have received so much negative attention or just attention in general, in the community that by the time they are ready to go to trial the defendant needs a jury from an altogether different community. By transferring the case it assures that the jury pool is one that does not have the pre-trial knowledge and exposure to the facts of the case thus giving the defendant a fair chance at a fair and valid trial.  

To fully understand the Change of Venue process it is important to know that changes of venue can also occur when the current venue isn’t the right one such as where the crime occurred in one county, but is being prosecuted in a different county. The court in the county where the crime did not occur may well lack of jurisdiction unless the county or city is in the same jurisdictional area. If this occurs then the case must be transferred to the correct jurisdiction.
                                                                         Reference
Scheb, J.M. and Scheb II, J.M. (2011). Criminal Law and Procedure 7th. Ed. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning.

 

Friday, January 8, 2016


                                                       Evidentiary Hearings 
By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
Not everyone is aware of what an evidentiary hearing is or when it is used or may occur. There  are many law enforcement officials who are somewhat confused as to the use of an evidentiary hearing in a criminal case. When using the term evidentiary hearing is a term that is used to describe a proceeding where evidence, such as witness or expert testimony and documentation is presented to the court in order to reach a decision on a particular matter. These hearings generally take place prior to trial. Now during these hearings information and evidence is presented to demonstrate if the item at issue being presented to the court for admission is admissible under the rule of evidence.

There are certain requirements that must be met prior to the court's scheduling of an evidentiary hearing. When scheduling an evidentiary hearing the defendant the defendant is required to and must establish his or her right to actually having an evidentiary hearing. This occurs when a defendant's motion and the government’s response to such motion establish a dispute as to material facts. To accomplish this a competent criminal defense attorney will need to allege specific and detailed facts to make the court aware of disputed issues of fact that must be resolved during a evidentiary hearing.  Regarding an evidentiary hearing it is popular to make general assertions of alleged constitutional violations; however, this will not compel a court to conduct an evidentiary hearing and the prosecutor will challenge motions by the defense alleging constitutional violations.

Looking at an evidentiary hearing from the standpoint of formulating defense strategy a pretrial motion and evidentiary hearings can be a valuable tool. The reason for this is that a pretrial suppression motion requiring an evidentiary hearing typically will lead to the disclosure of additional discovery earlier than usual. This discovery can be invaluable for trial preparation. It actually gives the defense an additional bite of the apple and the chance to see all of the evidence and also seeing how each witness testifies under the pressure of cross-examination. To examine this actual action it is technically an evidentiary hearing anytime a court hears and considers evidence to make a legal decision.  This can actually occurs in many different contexts, including a motion for belated appeal, hearing on a 3.850 motion for ineffective counsel (Klotter, 2000).  
An evidentiary hearing in criminal cases is most commonly referring to a hearing that occurs as part of a violation of probation case.  When someone charged with a violation of probation and does not resolve the case with an admission or dismissal of the violation of probation, the case will ultimately resolves with an evidentiary hearing.  An evidentiary hearing is the equivalent of a trial for a law violation and the defendant does not have all of the same rights that they would in a normal trial. During the evidentiary hearing, the State Attorney’s Office will call witnesses and present evidence attempting to prove the probationer violated their probation.  The Accused will also have the opportunity to call witnesses, present evidence and present argument (Klotter, 2000).
                                                          Reference
Klotter, J.C. (2000). Criminal Evidence 7th ed. Cincinnati, Ohio: Anderson Publishing Company.

Thursday, January 7, 2016

What is Hearsay Evidence ?


                                          What is Hearsay Evidence?
By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
The credibility of any witness's testimony depends upon three factors: (1) whether the witness accurately perceived what he or she described; (2) whether the witness retained an accurate memory of that perception; and (3) whether the witness's narration accurately conveys that perception. In order to be allowed to testify, the witness generally must take an oath, must be personally present at the trial, and must be subjected to cross-examination. These conditions promote the factors that lend themselves to the witness's credibility. The rule against Hearsay further bolsters the oath, personal presence, and cross-examination requirements.
Hearsay is a statement, made out of court, offered in court to prove the truth of the matter asserted. The statement may be oral or written, or it may be nonverbal conduct intended as an assertion, such as pointing to a crime suspect in a police line-up. The act of pointing in response to a request for identification is the same as stating, "He did it." Not all nonverbal conduct is intended as an assertion, of course.
EXAMPLE OF HEARSAY 
As an example of Hearsay a person usually opens an umbrella to stay dry, not to make the assertion, "It is raining." Sometimes, statements made out of court are not hearsay because they are not offered for the purpose of proving the truth of the matter asserted.
                                                       Reference
                    Hails, J. (2014). Criminal Evidence 8th ed. New York, NY: Cengage Publishing.

Spousal Priviliege and Gay Marriage


                              Spousal privilege and gay marriage
By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

In a major court decision in the area of marriages there was a ground breaking case decided in  June of 2015 wherein the United States Supreme Court ruled that all states must recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states; and every state must issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. This was a very dynamic move in that the Tenth Amendment of the Bill of Rights of the United States Constitution provides that decision like this are to be left up to the states legislators and yet the Supreme Court issued this holding which has had unsettling affects and now has a major effect on the Rules of Criminal Procedures in both the state and federal legal systems.

In the case of Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. ___ (2015), the United States Supreme Court, with this controversial decision answered the question of how courts will treat same-sex couples with respect to the two privileges discussed here. With the Supreme Court’s decision in this case it became very clear that the answer to the question was very simple in that the Supreme Court held that same-sex couples enjoy the same protections as do their opposite-sex counterparts. 

Courts and the federal and state governments recognize the spousal privilege in order to protect marital relationships from the harm that would befall them if spouses could be forced to testify against each other. However, this goal must be balanced against the competing need to avoid the harm caused when evidence is withheld from trials. Balancing these competing needs has resulted in various exceptions to, and underlying requirements for, the spousal privilege.



 

What is a Privilege as Relates to Admissiblity of Evidence

                      What is a Privilege as Relates to Admissibility of Evidence

By: Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.

Protection of Interests and Relationships
An examination of the Rules of Evidence demonstrates that unlike almost all other rules of evidence, the rules creating privileges are not designed to enhance the truth-finding function of court proceedings but they serve another purpose. The Rules of Evidence dealing with privileges address and acknowledge that other societal values such as privacy, the desire to encourage effective medical care or legal counsel, and governmental efficiency sometimes take precedent over the goal of ascertaining the truth in legal proceedings

Under the law there are certain relationships whose interests of privacy is protected and when someone tries to introduce evidence pertaining to one of the relationships then the court must weigh the value of having the facts be presented before the court against the protection of the interests and relationships, and during its deliberation it may decide to exclude relevant evidence from being admitted. Several personal interests and relationships have been and are currently regarded as having sufficient social importance to justify some sacrifice of sources of fact needed in the administration of justice. 
                                                                         Privileges
A “privilege” under the law is an exception to the universal rule that no one may refuse to give testimony or other evidence in a legal proceeding. This general rule promotes the interests of justice by ensuring fair trials on all of the available evidence.

A privilege, which is not a constitutional right, allows a person to object to their own or other’s testimony about communications within certain confidential relationships. By contrast, the right not to give testimony against oneself is a constitutional right (“taking the Fifth,” in common parlance). Exercising a constitutional right is not a “privilege,” and there are few exceptions to it.
Privileges are granted by state and federal law in order to protect certain important relationships. Among the best-known privileges are the attorney-client privilege and the doctor-patient privilege. The spousal relationship is granted a similar privilege.

Monday, January 4, 2016

Major Supreme Court 4th Amendment Decisions: Searches and Collection of Evidence


Major Supreme Court 4th Amendment Decisions: Searches and Collection of Evidence 
By Dr. Peter A. Barone, Esq.
One of the very first things that the defense attorney is going to examine and attempt to dissect in order to file a Motion to Suppress is did the law enforcement officials have the right to enter the location, after making sure it was safe and there were no additional victims or suspects, and perform a search of the scene, locating of items on the scene, collecting and impounding the items of evidence. If the law enforcement officials are violating the Fourth Amendment of the Bill of Rights of the Constitution of the United States of America.

Once an item is recognized as evidence it must be properly collected and preserved for either use as it is or to be sent to a laboratory for examination and or testing. However, in order for physical evidence to be admissible, it must have been legally obtained and this is the first place the defense is going to look to see if they can successfully present and win a motion to suppress the evidence collected by the law enforcement official and then attempting to be presented for acceptance as evidence by the prosecutor.
The courts have severely restricted the right of the police to search certain homicide crime scenes without a warrant. The United States Supreme Court has rendered three major decisions, which require police to obtain a search warrant to search a premise where the suspect and the deceased share a proprietary right to the premises. In all of the cases I worked as a homicide detective and as a major crimes felony prosecutor I always obtained a warrant and advised my detectives and investigators to get a warrant. When the law enforcement official obtains a search warrant the burden is shifted to the defense to prove that what the law enforcement officials did and located at the scene regarding evidence collection was wrong. If the law enforcement officials go onto a scene and do not get a warrant and locate items they deem to be valuable evidence and the defense brings a motion to suppress then the burden is on the prosecutor to prove, via the testimony of the law enforcement officials, that their actions were lawful and did not violate the fourth amendment of the United States Constitution.

In the case of Mincey v. Arizona 437 US 385 (1978) The Supreme Court advised that the police had violated the defendant's fourth amendment rights by the actions that had taken. Mincey, who was drug dealer and he had shot and killed an undercover narcotics officer during a drug raid. During this altercation Mincey was wounded and one of his companions were killed in the subsequent exchange of gun fire. The Narcotics officers, following procedure secured the premises and notified the Homicide personnel. The Homicide detectives arrived on the scnee and then they conducted an investigation during which hundreds of pieces of evidence were seized by the police over a three-day crime scene search. 

Mincey was arrested, charged and subsequently convicted of the murder of the undercover officer. However, on appeal the conviction was overturned by the Supreme Court, which maintained that Mincey's Fourth Amendment rights were violated and that the police should have secured a search warrant. The Supreme Court basically informed law enforcement that "There was not any homicide crime scene exception" to the Fourth Amendment. In this case the detectives should have secured and locked down the scene while they applied for a search warrant. The only two ways of conducting a search of this crime scene in a legally manner was to obtain consent by Mincey, which more than likely would not be granted, or to apply for and obtain a search warrant from a detached and neutral magistrate.

In 1984 The United States Supreme Court once again stepped in to address the same issue in Thompson v Louisiana 469 US 17 (1984). In the Thompson case, a woman who was reportedly depressed shot and killed her husband. The women then took an overdose of pills in an attempt to commit suicide after shooting and killing her husband. After taking the pills she then suddenly experienced a "change-of-heart" and decided she didn't want to die after-all. The woman then decided to call her daughter, who in turn called the Sheriff's Department, which dispatched an ambulance and deputies to the woman's home. The woman was transported to the hospital where she was treated. 
Investigators were called to the house and while they were in the residence they gathered evidence of the murder from the crime scene. Going back to Mincey and understanding that the woman and man were married and no one else lived in the home that left the husband, who was dead and the woman who killed him to give consent. Once the woman was taken to the hpsotial and the scene was checked for safety there was not additional reason for the law enforcement officials to remain on the scene to search. They did not have any exigent circumstances left, the man could not give consent and the woman was not going to give consent due to her mental state from the pills and the fact that she was the subject of the homicide. 
The woman was subsequently charged, tried and then convicted in the murder of her husband. The United States Supreme Court ruled against The State of Louisiana citing the Mincey Decision and the expectation of privacy provided in the Fourth Amendment. The woman's conviction was overturned. Once again the courts ruled that there was NO Homicide Exception and that the police were required to obtain a search warrant. Again, all law enforcement had to do was to lock down the house and then obtain a warrant from a neutral and detached magistrate.

In 1999 The Supreme Court once again stepped in to address the same issues raised in the Mincey and Thompson cases. This time it was Flippo v West Virginia 98 US 8770 (1999). Flippo was a pastor who reportedly was having a homosexual affair with a member of his congregation. His wife had discovered the relationship and was going to divorce him. Flippo convinced her that they should reconcile and talked her into going on a "camping trip." They went to a cabin in West Virginia that the pastor had rented. While at the cabin, the pastor reported that they had become victims of a home invasion during which his wife was fatally beaten and the pastor was slightly injured. The police were not impressed with Flippo's injuries. He was brought to a local hospital and "patched-up." Investigators, who were processing the crime scene, came upon Flippo's briefcase. Inside the briefcase were various pornographic pictures of Flippo and his male lover engaged in sexual activities. These materials, which represented "motive" as well as the other evidence seized from the cabin, were introduced into trial. Flippo was convicted of the murder of his wife. The conviction was overturned based on the same issues raised in Mincey and Thompson.
Again, once the wife’s body and Filppo left the scene there was no legal reason for law enforcement officials to remain on the scene and process the scene unless they requested consent from Filppo to do so. Here again the law enforcement officials should have locked down the scene and obtained a search warrant. It would have been wise to ask Filippo for consent and if he refused it could have been used by the investigators in the application for the search warrant.

It appears to be pretty obvious that the message that the United States Supreme Court is sending is that a Search Warrant should be secured before any crime scene search is undertaken and this is especially true regarding circumstances such as those previously described. However, my position has always been and is still now when I teach legal update classes that there is no reason why you cannot get a warrant unless there is something so devastating about to occur that totally precludes it.
In these decisions the United States Supreme Court has also made it pretty clear that there is no Homicide Scene Exception to the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution’s right to privacy. The message from the court is simple and needs to be adhered to which simply is that
Any EXTENDED SEARCH of a HOMICIDE SCENE, without consent or exigent circumstances requires a search warrant.


Homicides involving common-law relationships, husbands and wives, or family disputes may necessitate that the detective secure a warrant before a premises can be searched. · The professional homicide detective must be aware of the legal requirements for a warrant dependent upon both Supreme Court decisions as well as state law and case law within their own jurisdictional purview. An additional consideration is the dynamics of the event, which may present legitimate search warrant exceptions. The courts have recognized certain circumstances, which allow for exceptions to the requirement of a search warrant.
These exceptions are:

- Emergency or exigent circumstances
- Evidence in plain view
- Post arrest search of an individual for weapons and contraband, and
- Consent.

 
The use of the example of homicide cases here is presented to demonstrate one of the most heinous types of cases possible and notwithstanding the loss of life the court still advises that the law enforcement official must obtain a warrant for the search to be legal and not violate the Fourth Amendment rights of the individuals whose home or apartment is being searched.  

                                                               References

Mincey v. Arizona 437 US 385 (1978).
Thomas v. Louisiana 469 US 17 (1984).
Flippo v. West Virginia 98 US 8770 (1999).